When the rules change.

The midterm results are in, and like after every election, people are asking what it means for banking rules, for regulators, and for the paperwork that lands on a small business owner's desk. I've had three of those conversations already this week.

I'm not going to tell you who's right about any of it. That's not my job, and I'd only be guessing. What I can tell you is what I watched happen after elections during my years at the bank, because the pattern was much the same no matter how the results came out.

Helen owned a small chain of hardware stores when I was her banker. She'd been planning to tighten up her back office, with a second approval on payments and a monthly look at the bank statements by someone outside accounting. Then an election came, and she heard that oversight was about to loosen. She decided to wait and see what the new rules required before spending the money.

The rules took the better part of two years to change, and in the end they changed less than the headlines suggested. In the meantime, her accounts payable clerk wrote himself a little over thirty thousand dollars in checks. No regulator was ever going to catch that. A second approval and a monthly review probably would have.

That's the first thing I'd want you to take from this. Your internal controls were never really for the regulators. They're for you. Whatever happens in Washington, the person who can move money alone in your company can still move money alone.

A few other things I learned along the way.

Rules change slower than the news does. Most changes to financial regulation go through proposals, comment periods and effective dates. There's usually time to see something coming. A headline isn't a rule.

Changes can go both ways. Some oversight may loosen and some may tighten, and what loosens in one place often shows up somewhere else. Don't build your plans on one prediction.

Your bank won't change overnight either. Even when a rule relaxes, banks tend to keep their own procedures for a while, because their examiners, auditors and lawyers still have to sign off. The questions your banker asks probably won't stop next month.

Fraud doesn't follow the news. The fake invoices, the changed vendor bank details and the urgent wire requests will be here whatever the rules say. If anything, fraudsters like an office that's distracted.

So here's what I'd do over the next few months.

Pick one or two people you trust to tell you what actually changed, and when. Your CPA, your banker, your industry association. Let the rest go until something has an effective date.

Open the change-in-terms notices from your bank, your insurers and your payment providers. That's where real changes show up in your own accounts.

Don't pause a control because a rule might change. If it was worth doing last month, it's worth doing now.

And put a reminder on your calendar for early spring to sit down with your CPA and your banker and ask one simple question. Has anything changed that affects us?

Elections matter. But the most important controls in your business are the ones you decide on yourself, and those don't need anyone's permission to stay in place.

Previous
Previous

Clients are not your friends.

Next
Next

Read the fine print.