How much insurance is enough?

Insurance is the one bill every owner pays while hoping it turns out to be a waste of money. The premiums seem to go up every year, and every renewal someone asks a fair question. Do we really need all of this?

I'm not an insurance broker, and nothing here replaces a good one. But I spent years watching what happened to businesses on their worst day, and I have a view on how to think it through.

Owen runs an engineering firm with twelve people. Two years ago he nearly dropped his cyber policy at renewal, because the premium had jumped and nothing had ever happened. His broker talked him into keeping it.

Eight months later, his office manager got an email that looked like it came from a longtime subcontractor, with new bank details for the next invoice. She updated the record and paid. A little over forty thousand dollars went to a fraudster's account. Owen called his broker, relieved that he'd kept the policy.

Then he read it. The policy did cover that kind of fraud, but only up to a limit far smaller than the loss. He got back a small part of what went out the door.

Owen's problem wasn't too little insurance. It was not knowing what he had. That's the gap I see most often.

Here's how I'd think about it.

Start with what could close you. Not every possible loss, just the realistic bad days. A fraudulent wire. A client who says your work cost them money. A fire, a flood, a stolen truck full of equipment. A breach that means notifying your customers. A competitor who says you used their name or their design. Write them down with a rough number next to each.

Then ask what you could absorb. Look at your cash and your line of credit. A loss you could pay yourself and recover from is one you might choose to carry, maybe with a higher deductible and a lower premium. A loss that would sink you is the one to insure.

Read the sublimits and exclusions, not just the big number on the first page. A policy with a large limit can carry a much smaller limit for the exact thing you're worried about. Ask your broker to walk you through what would happen if your top three bad days happened tomorrow.

Check your contracts. Many client contracts, leases and loan agreements require certain coverage at certain amounts. Make sure what you carry matches what you've promised.

Let your controls do some of the work. Many insurers now ask about things like multi-factor authentication, call-back verification on payment changes and dual approval on wires. Good controls lower the odds you'll ever file a claim, and they can make you look like a better risk at renewal.

Review it every year, well ahead of renewal. Businesses change. New services, new contracts, more people, more data. Your coverage should change with them.

Owen still has his cyber policy. He raised the limit on payment fraud, added a call-back rule for any change to vendor bank details, and sits down with his broker for an hour a month before every renewal. He says he still hopes the policy is a waste of money. So do I.

There's no single right amount of insurance. But there is a right way to decide, and it starts with knowing which losses you can live with and which ones you can't.

Next
Next

Rich on paper.